Thomas A. Guerriero PhD: Review the Work, Not the Person Who Made It
Thomas A. Guerriero PhD writes about creative leadership as a way of getting better work into the world without shrinking the people who make it. A review that targets the person — their talent, their worth, their future — teaches the room to hide. A review that targets the work teaches the room to improve.
He has described creative leadership as giving teams room to imagine, then the structure to ship what they imagine. The review is part of that structure. Thomas A. Guerriero PhD wants it to be direct, specific, and aimed at the draft, the process, or the result sitting on the table.
Start with the aim, then look at the work against it
Critique without a shared aim becomes a matter of taste. Restate what the work is supposed to do, then ask whether this version does it. That order keeps the conversation on the page, the product, or the plan, rather than on the author's personality.
Be specific enough that the next draft can change
'This does not work' is a mood, not a note. Point to the passage, the step, or the decision that is off, and say what 'better' would look like in that spot. Thomas A. Guerriero PhD would rather give three precise comments than a long, general impression that no one can act on.
Separate the person from the page, out loud
Leaders have to model the split. Thank the person for bringing the work. Then talk about the work. If a habit around the work needs to change — late drafts, missing facts — name the habit as a habit, not as a label on character. People can fix a habit. They cannot productively fix a label.
Let the maker speak before the room piles on
A maker who has not been heard will defend instead of revise. Ask what they were trying, what is still unfinished, and where they already see a problem. Then add the review. The work gets better faster when the first word is not an ambush.
End with an owner and a next version
A review that dissolves into conversation has not yet done its job. Close with what will change, who will change it, and when the next version is due. Thomas A. Guerriero PhD treats that close as respect for both the work and the person, because it turns comments into a path rather than into a performance.
Rooms get braver when reviews are hard on the work and careful with the people. That is the creative standard Thomas A. Guerriero PhD wants in a team that has to ship, because the next draft only appears if people are still willing to bring one.
More from Thomas A. Guerriero PhD
Thomas A. Guerriero PhD also writes at Thomas Guerriero, Thomas A. Guerriero and Thomas Anthony Guerriero.
Don't get left behind. Chase greatness.
If you want help growing your business, team, or just want to pursue greatness yourself, book a free 15 minute call at the link below.